Empathy, Altruism & Agape:Perspectives on Love in Science and Religion
PresentersItineraryRegistrationTempleton FoundationFetzer InstituteContact
October 1-3, 1999, University Park Hotel at MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts
Path Home: Empathy, Altruism and Agape | Presenters or Itinerary

Samuel Oliner is Professor of Sociology at Humboldt State University and the Founder and General Director of the Altruistic Personality and Prosocial Behavior Institute as well as Founding Editor of the Humboldt Journal of Social Relations (an international refereed social science journal).

His books include: Race, Ethnicity and Gender: a Global Perspective (Kendall/Hunt, 1997, coeditor Phillip T. Gay); Who Shall Live: The Wilhelm Bachner Story (Academy Chicago Publishers, 1996, co-author Kathleen Lee); Toward a Caring Society: Ideas into Action (Praeger, 1995, co-author Pearl M. Oliner); Embracing the Other: Philosophical, Psychological, Historical Perspectives on Altruism (New York Univ. Press, 1992, co-editors Pearl M. Oliner, Lawrence Baron, Lawrence A Blum, Dennis L. Krebs, and M. Zuzanna Smolenska); The Altruistic Personality: Rescuers of Jews in Nazi Europe (The Free Press, 1988, co-author Pearl M. Oliner); Restless Memories: Recollections of the Holocaust Years (Judah L. Magnes Museum, 1979, 1986).

Work in progress: Based on data that we recently accumulated from Christian rescuers, Jewish rescuers, Military heroes, Carnegie heroes, Moral exemplars and Hospice volunteers, we are seeking common motivating factors that trigger the rescue and helping of diverse others.

Extraordinary Acts of Ordinary People: Faces of Heroism and Altruism

This paper has a twofold purpose: (1) to report results of our long-term study of rescuers of Jews during the Holocaust; and (2) to discuss our current expanded research on heroic and conventional altruism. Guided by the steering committee's suggestion that this conference address specific questions, I have chosen for this purpose to discuss the question of what psychological, social, and cultural factors influence altruism and caring. The first part of my presentation will focus on the research on heroism in Nazi-occupied Europe, specifically summarizing the findings which have come from the 14-year study on heroic rescuers, published in 1988 by myself and Pearl Oliner. That study was guided by three questions: (1) was rescue primarily a matter of opportunity; that is, external circumstances and situational factors, and if so, what were they? (2) was rescue primarily a matter of individual character, that is, personal attributes, and if so what were those traits and how were they acquired? (3) was rescue a matter of moral values/moral character?

The second part of this paper will deal with new research based on the same basic framework that guided the 1988 study, but which I have expanded to include five additional groups. In addition to the data we have accumulated at the Institute dealing with Gentile rescuers of Jews in Nazi-occupied Europe, we have recently gathered data on Jewish rescuers, heroism, and resistance during the same period; military heroes, individuals who have won the Congressional Medal of Honor or the Victoria Cross medals; Carnegie Heroes, individuals who risk their lives on behalf of strangers in the United States, Canada and their territorial waters. In 1904 a tragic accident occurred in one of Philanthropist Andrew Carnegie's mines in which 186 workers lost their lives. He was so moved and impressed with the heroic attempts of workers to rescue the victims, that he established the Carnegie Hero Fund. Since 1905 approximately 76,000 individual names have been submitted for an award, but only approximately 8,200 have received this prestigious award as of this date. We have interviewed in depth a sample of 210 men and women who won the award to gain insight about motivation.

Also included in the study are Moral Exemplars, specific individuals who had they not lived and acted for the benefit of humankind the world would have been the poorer for it. Finally, we have interviewed in depth a sample of 93 Hospice volunteers and 63 non-volunteers, to help us better understand why the Hospice volunteers help to comfort the dying and their loved ones.

Besides the research on Gentile rescuers of Jews, research on the additional five groups that we have included in this study has been completed. I will report in this paper the preliminary findings and trace some common factors that we find among the six groups. The data strongly suggests that there is no single motivating factor, but altruism seems to be one of the predominant factors in triggering altruistic behavior. I use a definition of altruism that relies on objective, measurable criteria. We have characterized a behavior as altruistic when (1) it is directed toward helping another, (2) it involves a high risk or sacrifice to the actor; (3) it is accompanied by no external reward, and (4) is voluntary.

I see the altruistic behavior of the six groups in this study as falling on a continuum, i.e., heroic altruism involves greater risk for the helper, whereas conventional altruism is not necessarily life threatening to the helper/actor. Thus, Gentile rescuers, Jewish rescuers, military heroes, and Carnegie rescuers fall on the heroic end of the altruistic continuum, while moral exemplars and volunteers fall on the conventional end of the continuum. While we do not detect all the motivating factors that I mention below, from preliminary analysis we discern that there are some common factors among the six groups. They are: parental role modeling, courage, empathy, learning caring norms, a prevailing moral code that one does not stand by and see another human being perish, self-esteem, social responsibility, self-efficacy, a sense of justice, a feeling that one can make a difference, intrinsic religious factors, agape, inclusiveness of others in the sphere of the rescuer's/helper's responsibility, need to help the community, the need for affiliation, self-enhancement, and reduction of guilt.

Friday, October 1, 1999

Elliott Sober, Ph.D.
University of Wisconsin
Mapping the Conceptual Terrain

Leda Cosmides, Ph.D. & John Tooby,Ph.D.
University of California, Santa Barbara
Friendship, engagement, and the Banker’s Paradox: Other pathways to the Evolution of Altruism

William H. Durham, Ph.D.
Stanford University
The Role of Culture in the Evolution of Altruism

David Sloan Wilson, Ph.D.
Binghamton University SUNY
The Rise and Fall and Rise and Fall of Altruism in Evolutionary Theory: Discussion with Audience

Frans B. M. de Waal, Ph. D.
Emory University, Yerkes Primate Living Links Center
Communication of Emotions and the Possibility of Sympathy in Monkeys and Apes

Antonio R. Damasio, M.D., Ph.D.
University of Iowa Hospital
The Neurobiology of Emotion

Hanna Damasio, M.D.
University of Iowa Hospital
Impaired Emotion and Social Behavior Following Brain Damage

William B. Hurlbut, M.D.
Stanford University
Empathy, Evolution and Ethics

Rev. Eugene Rivers
Ella J. Baker House

Saturday, October 2, 1999

Thomas R. Insel, M.D.
Emory University, Yerkes Primate Center
The Molecular Biology of Monogamy

Greg Fricchione, M.D.
Brigham and Women’s Hospital
Brain Evolution: Separation, Attachment and Agape

Jerome Kagan, Ph.D.
Harvard University
The Human Moral Sense

Don Browning, Ph.D.
The University of Chicago
Agape, Empathy and the Foundational/Nonfoundational Debate

Joan Eads, Zone Coordinator
L’Arche USA

Jeffrey P. Schloss, Ph.D. Westmont College
Is It Really More Blessed to Give than to Receive?: Emerging Questions in the Evolution of Radical Altruism

Edith Wyschogrod, Ph.D.
Rice University Pythagorean Bodies and the Body of Altruism

Stephen J. Pope, Ph.D.
Boston College
The Ordering of Love

Rev. Robert Hamerton-Kelly
Woodside Village Church
Emergence of Radical Love in the Biblical Tradition

Dame Cicely Saunders
St. Christopher’s Hospice

Sunday, October 3, 1999

Samuel P. Oliner, Ph.D.
Altruistic Personality and Prosocial Behavior Institute
Extraordinary Acts of Ordinary People: Faces of Heroism and Altruism

Pearl Oliner, Ph.D.
California State University - Humboldt
Ingroup and Outgroup Altruism: Protestants and Catholics

Kristen Renwick Monroe, Ph.D.
University of California
How Identity and Perspective Constrain Choice

Dan Batson, Ph.D.
University of Kansas
Addressing the Altruism Question Experimentally

V.S. Ramachandran, Ph.D.
University of California, San Diego
Neural Basis of Empathy and of Artistic Experience

Lynn G. Underwood, Ph.D.
Fetzer Institute
The Human Experience of Agape & Compassion: Conceptual Mapping and Data from Selected Studies

Ruben L.F. Habito, Ph.D.
Southern Methodist University
Compiversity Pythagorean Bodies and the Body of Altruism

Stephen J. Pope, Ph.D.
Boston College
The Ordering of Love

Rev. Robert Hamerton-Kelly
Woodside Village Church
Emergence of Radical Love in the Biblical Tradition

Dame Cicely Saunders
St. Christopher’s Hospice

John Templeton Foundation
c/o altruisticlove.org
Five Radnor Corporate Center
Suite 100
100 Matsonford Road
Radnor, PA 19087

Phone: (610) 687-8942
Fax: (610) 687-8961

General Info: altruism@templeton.org
Press Info: thompson@templeton.org

Please be sure to include your name, address and daytime telephone number in your correspondence.
Fetzer Institute
9292 West KL Avenue
Kalamazoo, MI 49009
Phone: 616-375-2000
Fax: 616-372-2163

Site design by Digital Design Works, Inc.an affiliate of BTC Marketing.

If you have any questions, comments or suggestions please E-mail us.